Insurer's Compensation for Fire-Damaged Property Sparks Controversy
Insurer's Compensation for Fire-Damaged Property Sparks Controversy
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
A property owner’s attempt to increase his fire damage compensation has been thwarted after admitting to deliberately underinsuring his property to cut costs.
The controversy has highlighted potential pitfalls for homeowners seeking to reduce insurance premiums.
Hollard Insurance had initially declined the claim following a fire in October 2021, pointing to non-disclosure issues. However, upon the homeowner's appeal to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), the insurer revised its stance.
Hollard agreed to settle the claim with a payment of $415,937, allocating $300,437 for the building damage and $12,875 for contents, in addition to payments for temporary housing, non-financial loss compensation, professional fees, and accrued interest.
Despite this, the property owner contended the settlement was not fair, arguing his home and belongings were underinsured. Hollard defended the settlement, noting it was still higher than the policy’s insured amounts of $240,350 for the home and $10,300 for the contents.
The homeowner had purchased the policy through his bank, which acted as an authorised representative of the insurer. He claimed the bank's employee had provided financial advice without adequately understanding his financial situation or reviewing his personal circumstances. Additionally, he mentioned not receiving the policy documents.
In its ruling, the AFCA stated that based on the information provided, there was no substantial evidence that the bank's representative offered personalized advice.
“Though the complainant suggested that the representative promised to handle all the coverage details, the panel did not find sufficient proof that personal advice was given,” noted the AFCA.
The authority further emphasized that during an interview with the insurer, the complainant had confirmed receiving and reviewing the policy's product disclosure statement and insurance certificate, thus acknowledging the insured amounts and the underinsurance to reduce premiums.
“I didn’t foresee this type of incident happening, so I underinsured some things to pay a lower premium,” admitted the complainant.
With this acknowledgment, the AFCA supported the insurer's position to settle based on the confessed amount.
Furthermore, the AFCA dismissed the complainant’s request for additional legal fees amounting to $27,500, over and above the $5,000 already provided by Hollard. The complainant claimed that his cognitive impairment made self-representation unfeasible.
But the authority concluded that there was inadequate evidence to substantiate the extent of his cognitive impairment and asserted that Hollard had justifiable reasons to scrutinize the claim, leading to legal expenditures.
Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.
The Australian insurance industry is currently undergoing a significant transformation, marked by a surge in mergers and acquisitions (M&A). This trend is reshaping the market landscape, as companies seek to enhance their competitive edge and adapt to evolving regulatory and technological environments. - read more
In a significant development for Australia's construction sector, MECON has announced an increase in its underwriting capacity, now offering coverage up to $120 million for single projects. This enhancement, effective from March 10, 2026, applies to Section 1 (Material Damage) and includes Section 2 (Public Liability), providing more robust insurance solutions for larger and more complex construction endeavors. - read more
Australia's construction industry is currently facing significant challenges as rising costs reshape the insurance claims landscape. A recent report by Crawford & Company highlights that construction expenses are increasing at a rate faster than general consumer prices, with the Building Cost Index (BCI) rising nearly 5% annually. This trend is particularly evident in cities like Brisbane and Perth, where strong demand, logistical challenges, and a persistent shortage of skilled labour contribute to escalating costs. - read more
The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) has expressed strong support for the proposed Competition and Consumer Amendment (Unfair Trading Practices) Bill 2026. This legislation seeks to introduce a general prohibition on unfair trading practices within Australian Consumer Law, thereby enhancing regulatory powers to address predatory operators in the insurance industry. - read more
The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) has implemented emergency measures to address significant concerns within the commercial auto insurance sector. In response to widespread industry protests over substantial premium increases, APRA has introduced regulations aimed at safeguarding transport operators from financial hardship. - read more
Recent data from Marsh Risk's Global Insurance Market Index indicates a substantial decline in Australian commercial insurance rates. In the fourth quarter of 2025, rates fell by 12%, representing the most significant drop among the eight regions monitored by the index. This trend continues the downward trajectory observed since early 2024. - read more
In June 2025, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) provided an update on their joint review of life insurance premium practices. This initiative was prompted by concerns over frequent and substantial premium increases that may not align with policy terms or policyholder expectations. - read more
In August 2025, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) released findings from a review of direct life insurance sales practices, uncovering persistent deficiencies despite previous regulatory interventions. - read more
Swiss Re Life & Health Australia has announced a suspension of new life insurance business activities in the country, effective October 2025. This decision stems from concerns over the sustainability of Total Permanent Disability (TPD) insurance products, which have seen a significant rise in claims, particularly related to mental health. - read more
Damien Mu, CEO of AIA Australia, has raised concerns about the sustainability of the current life insurance model, citing a significant increase in mental health claims and economic volatility. Speaking at the company's recent Thrive for Life presentation, Mu emphasised that the industry is facing structural changes driven by these factors. - read more
Farming is a vital industry in Australia, requiring significant investment in equipment, crops, livestock, and labour. As with any major investment, protecting it is crucial. That's where farm insurance comes in. - read more
Farming in Australia is more than just a way of life; it is a critical sector that supports the nation’s economy and food supply. However, managing a farm comes with its own set of unique risks. From natural disasters to equipment failures, farmers face numerous challenges that can impact their livelihood. - read more
Crop insurance is a type of insurance policy designed to protect farmers from the financial losses that arise from damages to their crops. This could be due to various risks, including adverse weather conditions, pests, and diseases. - read more
Farming is much more than an occupation; it's a way of life and a heritage that often spans generations. In today's ever-evolving agricultural landscape, embracing modern practices while preserving your farm's future has never been more crucial. Estate planning emerges as a pivotal strategy for safeguarding your agricultural legacy, ensuring that your hard-earned investments and the land you hold dear are passed on according to your wishes. - read more
For Australian farmers, livestock is more than just a vital asset; it's the heartbeat of their livelihood. In a land where the sunburnt plains are as relentless as they are beautiful, protecting your herd isn't just a duty; it's a necessity. That's where livestock insurance comes into play—a shield against the unpredictability of Mother Nature. - read more
Farming, at its core, is an enterprise fraught with uncertainty. Weather calamities, pests, diseases, and fluctuating market conditions can all impact the output and quality of produce. This is where crop insurance proves its worth, serving as a safety net for farmers against the myriad risks they face each season. - read more
Hobby farming has become increasingly popular in Australia, with many individuals and families embracing the joys of growing their own produce, raising livestock, and enjoying a rural lifestyle. Whether it's a small vegetable garden, a few chickens, or a larger mixed farming operation, hobby farms offer both relaxation and a connection to nature. - read more
Farming is inherently risky. With factors like weather, pests, and market fluctuations affecting crops, it's crucial to manage these risks effectively. - read more
Welcome to the defining era where technology and agriculture entwine, bringing forth the digital farmer's era. With the evolution of agribusiness in the tech age, comes an array of new tools, opportunities, and risks. As a custodian of the earth and steward of the latest innovations, safeguarding your digital farm is just as crucial as nurturing your crops and livestock. - read more
In the dynamic world of Australian agriculture, farm equipment plays a crucial role in the day-to-day operations of farms. From tractors to harvesters, having the right machinery means managing your farm more efficiently. However, the high value of this equipment makes it essential to protect it adequately through insurance. - read more
Need a Quote?
Start your free farm insurance quote comparison here.
Knowledgebase
Grace Period: A time period after the premium is due during which an insurance policy remains in force even if the premium has not yet been paid.