Home Parking Dilemma Leads to Insurance Dispute Loss

2

The insurer, SGUAS, denied the claim based on a clause that excluded coverage for vehicles left on the street between 10pm and 5am. The woman's car was stolen at 2am from directly outside her house, with the thieves gaining access by breaking into her home and taking the keys.

According to a police report, the location of the car would not have deterred the thieves, who broke a window to enter the house. “Regardless of where the car was parked, the offenders would have successfully taken the vehicle," stated the report.

The car owner revealed that she bought her insurance through a broker and relied on him for managing all details. She admitted to frequently parking on the street because of the difficulty in maneuvering her car into the narrow driveway and carport of her new home.

During the investigation, her broker argued to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) that the car would have been stolen regardless of its parking spot. However, AFCA maintained that the insurer was not liable as the homeowner did not inform them of her regular street parking, a critical deviation from the declared parking arrangements.

AFCA's ombudsman expressed sympathy for the homeowner's plight but upheld the policy's exclusion for overnight street parking. "It seems this practice was established due to the inaccessible driveway, yet the policy clearly stipulates the necessity to inform the insurer of any such changes," the ombudsman noted.

"The homeowner consistently parked on the street overnight, thereby invalidating her insurance claim due to the policy's terms. The failure to communicate this change prejudiced the insurer’s ability to assess the risk properly, justifying the claim denial," the AFCA representative explained.

AFCA further noted that street parking significantly increases the risk of theft, a factor emphasized in the insurer’s underwriting guidelines. “Even though the thieves acted boldly, the information provided by the insurer indicates a higher theft risk for cars parked on the road,” it stated.

At the inception of the policy, the homeowner’s broker had conveyed detailed parking arrangements to the insurer, even providing a picture of the carport. Yet, this information became obsolete when the homeowner developed a habit of street parking without updating the insurer.

This case serves as a stark reminder of the crucial role precise adherence to insurance policy terms plays. Policyholders should communicate any changes in their circumstances to ensure their coverage remains valid. For more details, you can refer to the original ruling by AFCA.

Published:Monday, 9th Sep 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Life Insurance Sector to Develop New Mental Health Claims Framework

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

A significant update is on the horizon for mental health claims within the Australian life insurance sector. The Council of Australian Life Insurers (CALI) has announced the creation of a new assessment framework. This move will be developed in collaboration with consumer advocates, medical specialists, and other key stakeholders. The forthcoming plan aims to establish minimum standards for evaluating claims, ensuring that they are based on consistent and evidence-based criteria. - read more

WFI and AgCarE Join Forces to Reward Sustainable Farming Practices

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

In a significant move towards promoting sustainable agriculture, WFI Insurance has partnered with AgCarE, a certification program developed by AgForce, to offer premium reductions to farmers who achieve AgCarE certification. This collaboration aims to enhance financial, environmental, and social outcomes for Australian farmers and rural communities. - read more

Rising Insurance Costs Challenge Australian Farmers as Extreme Weather Intensifies

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australian farmers are confronting a significant surge in insurance premiums, a trend largely attributed to the increasing frequency and severity of extreme weather events. Over the past few years, many farmers have reported that their insurance bills have more than doubled, with annual premiums exceeding $100,000. - read more

Diversifying Small Farms Open New Avenues for Insurance Brokers

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

The landscape of Australian agriculture is evolving as small commercial farms increasingly diversify their operations to enhance income and sustainability. This shift presents both challenges and opportunities for insurance brokers, as new ventures introduce complex risk management needs. - read more

Addressing the Surge in Collision Risks for Australian Fleet Operators

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australia's transport and haulage sector is currently navigating a period of heightened operational risk, marked by an uptick in both the frequency and severity of motor collision claims. This trend underscores the pressing need for fleet operators to adopt proactive risk management strategies and leverage advanced insurance solutions to safeguard their operations. - read more

Understanding the Impact of Inattention and Speed on Australian Truck Crashes

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

The National Truck Accident Research Centre (NTARC) has released its 2025 Major Incident Investigation Report, shedding light on the primary human factors contributing to significant truck crashes across Australia. The findings emphasize the critical roles of inattention, distraction, and inappropriate speed in these incidents, underscoring the necessity for targeted safety interventions within the transport industry. - read more

Navigating the Rise in Comprehensive Car Insurance Premiums for Australian Drivers

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australian motorists are experiencing continued pressure from rising comprehensive car insurance premiums, with average annual costs increasing by 5.8% between 2024 and 2025. This translates to an average increase of $122, bringing the typical comprehensive policy to $2,226, up from $2,104 a year earlier. - read more

Understanding the Surge in Home Insurance Premiums Across Australia

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australian homeowners are experiencing notable increases in home insurance premiums, a trend largely driven by the escalating frequency and severity of extreme weather events. Recent data indicates that average annual premiums for new home and contents policies have risen by 14%, equating to an additional $343 per year for policyholders. This surge is a direct response to the substantial claims resulting from natural disasters that have impacted various regions across the country. - read more

The Vital Role of Reinsurance in Safeguarding Australian Insurers

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Reinsurance has emerged as a cornerstone of financial stability for Australian insurers, effectively shielding them from potential losses that could have reached up to $70 billion. In the past financial year, general insurers in Australia invested approximately AUD2.5 billion in reinsurance, a strategic move that has proven invaluable in mitigating the financial impact of increasingly frequent and severe natural disasters. - read more

Taxi Driver Wins Case Against Late Reporting Excess on Crash Claim

20 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has overturned a $2500 late reporting excess fee applied to a taxi driver's insurance claim. The charge was initially levied after he lodged a claim late following a December 2023 accident for which he was at fault, resulting in minor damage to his vehicle. - read more

Click for more Insurance News