Opposition Leader Peter Dutton’s proposal to dismantle major insurance companies to boost competitiveness and reduce premiums has sparked significant pushback from industry brokers.
The suggestion, criticized as ineffective, faces opposition from those who argue that the root causes of high premiums lie elsewhere.
As noted by insurtech pioneer Scott Norton, whose alternatives have gained traction, the real issue lies in inadequate disaster preparedness. According to broker Petara Tanuvasa, premium increases are driven by insufficient measures like flood defences and firebreaks. These gaps lead insurers to elevate premiums to offset rising claims. Taxes further burden consumers, with levies such as GST, stamp duties, and fire service contributions inflating costs more.
Stacy Finnegan, COO of RepX, backed Norton’s viewpoint and stressed that local governments play a critical role in reducing home insurance claims. Enforcing building standards, avoiding development in risk-prone areas, and incorporating flood and fire-resistant requirements are crucial steps. "We stand united against severe weather patterns that heighten market volatility, instead of targeting the industry unfairly," she commented.
Additionally, some industry voices, like Tasmanian broker Greg Lewer, suggest that the real financial burdens come from other sectors. Lewer highlights the disparity between insurance and bank profits, noting that while 85 insurers collectively earned $5.9 billion last year, the Commonwealth Bank of Australia alone garnered $5.1 billion in half that time.
Given the challenges, industry stakeholders believe addressing fundamental issues rather than resorting to divestment is vital for achieving sustainable premium reductions and fostering healthy market competition.
As the debate unfolds, it remains to be seen whether policymakers will shift focus towards holistic solutions that encompass broader economic and environmental strategies, addressing taxes, disaster mitigation, and proactive local governance.
Published:Thursday, 6th Mar 2025 Source: Paige Estritori
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) is calling on insurers to enhance their communication regarding premium increases to help resolve disputes more effectively and fairly. The authority suggests that offering flexible payment options could also aid in managing disputes. - read more
Leading Australian life insurer TAL has reported a substantial $4.7 billion in life insurance claims paid over the 12 months ending March 31, 2025. This figure underscores the significant role life insurers play in providing financial support to Australians during challenging times. - read more
Encompass Protection has been honored with the Income Protection Insurance Award at the 2025 Money Magazine Life Insurance Awards. This accolade reflects the company's commitment to providing exceptional coverage and service to Australians seeking income protection solutions. - read more
In a significant development for Australia's marine insurance sector, Rhodian Group has unveiled its latest venture, Marinex Underwriting. This new agency is set to provide specialised marine insurance products tailored to the unique needs of the Australian market. - read more
Network Marine Insurance has recently elevated its commitment to Australia's marina industry by becoming a Bronze Sponsor of the Marina Industries Association (MIA). This partnership underscores the company's dedication to supporting the growth and sustainability of marinas across the nation. - read more
Australian consumers should brace for continued increases in insurance premiums, albeit at a moderated pace, according to Nick Hawkins, CEO of Insurance Australia Group (IAG). The company recently reported a significant 91% rise in net profit for the first half of the fiscal year ending December 31, 2024, reaching $778 million. This surge is largely attributed to favourable weather conditions and a reduction in claims. - read more
In a significant move within the Australian insurance sector, Allianz Australia has successfully acquired RAA Insurance for $642 million. This acquisition, approved by the competition regulator on June 12, 2025, marks a strategic expansion for Allianz into the South Australian market. - read more
Australian businesses are currently navigating a complex and evolving risk landscape, marked by increased exposures across various domains. A recent report from Gallagher highlights several key areas contributing to this heightened risk environment. - read more
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has commenced Federal Court proceedings against RACQ Insurance, a subsidiary of Insurance Australia Group (IAG), alleging that the insurer misled over 570,000 customers through deceptive premium comparison pricing in renewal notices issued between September 2019 and December 2024. - read more
Australia's insurance industry has reported an after-tax profit of $6.1 billion for the year 2024, a figure that is three times higher than the five-year average of $2 billion. This substantial increase is attributed to significant premium hikes and a relatively benign year for natural disasters. - read more
As the backbone of Australian agriculture, farm equipment plays an essential role in day-to-day operations across our expansive and diverse landscapes. From the vast wheat belts to the tropical fruit farms, machinery ensures efficiency and productivity in the face of constant challenges. But with reliance on such equipment comes significant risk—the financial burden of damage or loss can be devastating to a farmer's livelihood. - read more
Farming is a vital industry in Australia, requiring significant investment in equipment, crops, livestock, and labour. As with any major investment, protecting it is crucial. That's where farm insurance comes in. - read more
Farming is much more than an occupation; it's a way of life and a heritage that often spans generations. In today's ever-evolving agricultural landscape, embracing modern practices while preserving your farm's future has never been more crucial. Estate planning emerges as a pivotal strategy for safeguarding your agricultural legacy, ensuring that your hard-earned investments and the land you hold dear are passed on according to your wishes. - read more
Farming, at its core, is an enterprise fraught with uncertainty. Weather calamities, pests, diseases, and fluctuating market conditions can all impact the output and quality of produce. This is where crop insurance proves its worth, serving as a safety net for farmers against the myriad risks they face each season. - read more
Crop insurance is a type of insurance policy designed to protect farmers from the financial losses that arise from damages to their crops. This could be due to various risks, including adverse weather conditions, pests, and diseases. - read more
Farming in Australia is not just a job, it's a way of life. However, it’s also a livelihood that comes with its own unique set of risks. From unexpected weather events to machinery breakdowns, the life of an Australian farmer is fraught with uncertainties. - read more
In the dynamic world of Australian agriculture, farm equipment plays a crucial role in the day-to-day operations of farms. From tractors to harvesters, having the right machinery means managing your farm more efficiently. However, the high value of this equipment makes it essential to protect it adequately through insurance. - read more
In the world of agriculture, having the right insurance coverage is essential. Farming is a high-risk industry that deals with unpredictable elements, and insuring your farm equipment can safeguard your livelihood. - read more
For Australian farmers, livestock is more than just a vital asset; it's the heartbeat of their livelihood. In a land where the sunburnt plains are as relentless as they are beautiful, protecting your herd isn't just a duty; it's a necessity. That's where livestock insurance comes into play—a shield against the unpredictability of Mother Nature. - read more
Farm liability insurance is a type of coverage that protects farmers from financial losses due to legal claims and lawsuits. This insurance is crucial for safeguarding your farm against various liabilities that may arise from farm operations. - read more
Need a Quote?
Start your free farm insurance quote comparison here.
Knowledgebase
Surrender Value: The amount of money an insurance policyholder will receive if they voluntarily terminate the policy before it matures.