Consumer Advocates Criticise Insurers Over 'Poverty Premiums' and 'Loyalty Taxes'

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

Consumer advocacy groups have voiced strong opposition to the insurance industry's decision to reject recommendations designed to eliminate practices that disadvantage consumers, including charging higher rates for monthly bill payments and increasing renewal premiums for loyal customers.

The Financial Rights Legal Centre has cited ongoing reports from consumers being adversely affected by these pricing practices, which they refer to as a "poverty premium" and a "loyalty tax."

The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) recently published an action plan in response to 150 recommendations from the parliamentary floods inquiry and a comprehensive review of the industry code of practice. Despite the consensus among both reviews that insurers should not charge more for monthly payments than they do for annual ones, and renewal premiums should not surpass those offered to new customers, the ICA asserts that enforcing pricing policies is not within the code's remit due to competition law restrictions.

Continuous concerns have been raised about the code's enforceability and the numerous recommendations the ICA did not fully endorse. Financial Rights Legal Centre's Drew MacRae stated that around 38 recommendations are still under consideration, or have been delegated to individual companies to decide upon.

Financial Counselling Australia has expressed significant concern that the ICA's action plan does not actively address inequitable pricing practices. According to their disaster recovery co-ordinator, Louise Hayes, it is essential for insurers to address these unfair practices and incorporate them into the industry code to ensure accountability and equity.

While the ICA's action plan includes some positive initiatives, such as a framework for assisting vulnerable customers, it also drew criticism for lacking a firm commitment to enforceability. The recommendations from the inquiry suggested these policies should be embedded contractually within product disclosure statements to strengthen consumer protection.

Stephanie Tonkin, CEO of Consumer Action Law Centre, highlights the importance of rebuilding consumer trust, especially following the response to the 2022 floods. She stresses that the industry's focus should shift more towards customer welfare rather than profitability, with enforceable actions driving this change.

ICA CEO Andrew Hall noted that the action plan aims to guide industry changes over the coming years with a central focus on enhancing the customer experience. He acknowledged the necessity of collaborating with consumer advocates, regulators, and the government to tackle the underlying issues cited in the reviews.

Published:Wednesday, 26th Mar 2025
Author: Paige Estritori

Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Significant Decline in Australian Commercial Insurance Rates

25 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori

In the final quarter of 2025, Australian commercial insurance rates experienced a substantial decline of 12%, marking the most significant drop among the eight regions monitored by Marsh Risk's Global Insurance Market Index. This trend reflects a broader pattern of decreasing rates that began in early 2024, with the Pacific region, predominantly Australia, leading the way. - read more

Human Factors Dominate Causes of Major Truck Crashes in Australia

25 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori

The National Truck Accident Research Centre's 2025 Major Incident Investigation Report, supported by NTI, has identified human error as the predominant cause of major truck crashes in Australia. The report indicates that factors such as inattention, distraction, and inappropriate speed account for a significant proportion of these incidents. - read more

ASIC Launches Review into Motor Insurance Pricing Practices

25 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has initiated a comprehensive review into the accuracy and transparency of motor insurance pricing among major insurers, covering approximately two-thirds of the car insurance market. This investigation aims to ensure that insurers comply with legal disclosure requirements and provide clear explanations for premium calculations. - read more