Homeowner Triumphs in Ground Movement Damage Claim

4

The homeowner noticed cracking in a load-bearing wall on July 8, 2022, and quickly linked the issue to a leaking water main he discovered the next day. He attributed the cracking and additional damage throughout his house to ground movement from the leak.

Independent assessments commissioned by Hollard Insurance presented contrasting views. A plumber observed substantial leakage, resulting in damp conditions and soaking of nearby stumps. He suspected this might have led to slight settlement problems and further cracking within the property, particularly in the kitchen area.

Hollard's engineer, however, inspected the house roughly a month later. Their report downplayed the leaking pipe, chalking up the damage to long-term issues associated with the soil's properties, including seasonal moisture changes and environmental causes. According to the engineer, the cracking damage predated the observed leak and was related to the house's history.

The homeowner highlighted extensive renovation work conducted between 2016 and 2019 to stabilize the foundations of his 1930s-era home, including underpinning and relevelling. He noted the lack of substantial cracking until the sudden appearance of damage in July 2022.

AFCA’s evaluation supported the homeowner’s evidence that the damage in the newer parts of the house was a recent development. Video footage and the plumber's testimony showed significant leakage, undermining the engineer's less critical assessment. AFCA also questioned the conclusiveness of the engineer's floor-level survey.

"While there is a history of movement-related damage, the noted cracking around the extension did not follow this pattern," AFCA determined. According to the authority, the factors cited by the engineer involved gradual, long-term damage, but in this case, the damage seemingly appeared suddenly due to the leaking pipe.

In its final ruling, AFCA concluded that the homeowner's losses likely resulted from an unexpected, sudden release of water. Consequently, Hollard Insurance would be responsible for repairing the assessed damage or covering repair costs. However, unrelated damage not connected to the leak would be excluded from coverage.

The case underscores the importance of independent reviews and cultivates awareness about homeowners' rights amidst damage disputes. AFCA's decision shines a light on their role in ensuring fair evaluations are considered in claim disputes.

This ruling is reported with original insights from an article appearing in Insurance News.

Published:Monday, 15th Jul 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Impact of Trump Tariffs on Global Insurance Industry 11 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori According to Swiss Re’s latest Sigma report, the growth of property and casualty premiums is moderating in both Australia and globally. This moderation is primarily driven by a slowdown in rate hikes. Additionally, the Trump administration's America First trade policy is putting further pressure on the insurance sector. - read more

Navigating Changes in Australia's Life Insurance Advice Landscape 10 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The conversation on the shifting dynamics in Australia's life insurance advice sector featured Zurich Australia's head of adviser channel, Kieran Forde, and Hayes & Co director, Katherine Hayes. They engaged with editor Chris Dastoor to spotlight the current market conditions and future prospects for financial advisers in this domain. - read more

ASIC Challenges Federal Court's 'Fair Term' Ruling 09 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is appealing a Federal Court decision regarding the wording of a 'pre-existing condition' clause in certain HCF Life insurance products. The court previously determined that while the wording had the potential to mislead consumers, it did not constitute an unfair contract term under the current laws set out in the ASIC Act 2001. - read more

ICA Advocates for Strata Law Reform in the ACT to Enhance Building Management 08 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) is urging the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) to adopt strata transparency regulations, aiming to enhance oversight of building repairs and maintenance by owners’ committees. This call was made during a parliamentary inquiry, where the ICA pushed for measures akin to recent legislative changes in New South Wales. - read more

Tasmanian Government Insurance Proposal Faces Industry Backlash 07 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The Tasmanian government's recent proposal to establish a state-run insurance entity has drawn significant criticism from key players in the insurance industry. The plan, spearheaded by Premier Jeremy Rockliff, aims to expand the Motor Accidents Insurance Board into a broader service named TasInsure, offering products including home and contents insurance, small business coverage, and more. The RACT, a major player in Tasmania's insurance sector, expressed considerable concern, labelling the initiative as a simplistic answer to complex problems. - read more

Asbestos Scare Leaves Hospitality Business Uninsured 04 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The discovery of asbestos-contaminated mulch in a Sydney park led to the cancellation of a festival, resulting in significant financial losses for a hospitality business. Despite these setbacks, the company's claim for coverage under its business interruption (BI) policy was rejected. - read more

Landmark NSW Decision: Dog Walking Costs Covered in Car Crash Injury Claims 03 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori In a groundbreaking decision by the NSW Personal Injury Commission, an insurer has been directed to cover the costs of dog walking services for a car crash victim. The commission ruled that these services classify as domestic assistance under the state’s Motor Accident Injuries Act. This case could pave the way for broader interpretations of 'attendant care services' for claimants. - read more

Extreme Weather Drives $1.8 Billion in First Half Losses for Australian Insurers 03 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori Extreme weather events in Australia have resulted in significant financial impacts for insurers, tallying $1.83 billion in losses during the first half of the year. This comes as insurance companies gear up for further claims linked to ongoing severe weather in New South Wales. - read more

ClearView Names New Underwriting Head Amidst Strategic Changes 30 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori ASX-listed life insurer ClearView has announced the appointment of Peter Tilocca as Head of Underwriting, coinciding with key updates to its underwriting standards and definitions. Tilocca's extensive two-decade career in Australian underwriting includes leadership roles at Zurich, Noble Oak, One Path Life, and RGA Australia. His new role with ClearView commenced on 30 June. - read more

Ombudsman Supports Theft Claimant in Home Business Coverage Dispute 30 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori A recent case has seen a policyholder triumph over her insurer after the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) ruled in her favour following a contentious dispute regarding home business operations. The controversy arose when the woman's theft claim was denied by her insurance provider, IAG, over allegations of fraudulent misrepresentation about the use of her rental property. - read more